Welcome to Sugar Bowl Lancaster
Sugar Bowl Lancaster is a delightful eatery located in the heart of Lancaster, PA. Known for its extensive menu, it caters to diverse tastes, offering everything from scrumptious personal pizzas to mouthwatering cheeseburger subs that leave a lasting impression. Customers praise the friendly staff and attentive service, creating a welcoming atmosphere that feels both cozy and vibrant. The freshly prepared dishes, like the crispy bacon-laden BLT and authentic Italian sandwiches, showcase quality ingredients and generous portions, making every meal memorable. With homemade cookies and a solid selection of drinks, Sugar Bowl Lancaster is a hidden gem that invites repeat visits.
Sugar Bowl Lancaster: Reviews & Ratings
Haven't heard of this place yet before I moved just up the block from there. I must share with you that the Pizza is great especially the personal small pie. Friendly and helpful staff is worth the time and money. The menu is extensive there's something for everyone you'll not be disappointed.
Mannnnn don’t get me started on the cheeseburger subs, chef’s kiss from the soft roll, to the fresh onions, perfect amount of Mayo, melts in your mouth. Me and the boys were getting this multiple days a week while working in the area. Owner is super cool! Don’t sleep on the homemade cookies. Pizza is bomb as well. But the cheeseburger subs definitely a hole in the wall!
i just went here for the first time. i will definitely be back again. their menu is huge and their prices are fair for the amount of food you get. i got a blt, and it was stuffed. i also got a half order of fries but with the amount they gave me it easily could've been a full order. the blt had crispy bacon, fresh produce, the perf amount of mayo and toasted bread. it was one of the best blts i ever had anywhere. the fries were hot and fresh. nothing was overly greasy so i didn't feel sick afterwards at all like some other places leave me feeling. i left feeling comfortably full. they also have a great selection of bottled drinks. my entire meal was only 10, whereas some other restaurants would charge me that just for the sandwich. the atmosphere was also comfy. it was giving roller rink party room vibes but cleaner and more sophisticated if that makes any sense. the person who took our order was very sweet and even though there was a table of napkins and condiments near us she took the time to bring us a stack of napkins and a bottle of ketchup herself. so overall everything about this place is great, i have no complaints, and i will for sure be back soon to try their other menu items. 3
The Italian sandwich was amazing. Real Italian meats and not just cooked salami and bologna. The fries were hot and crispy. The service great. Able to order at the counter and it was brought to our table.
Stopped by since it was nearby where we were visiting. Great pizza. Crispy and buttery crust good sauce and the right amount of cheese. Freindly service by people that truly seemed happy that we were there.
Nice mom and pop place.
Do you like a quality gyro or Greek salad? If so, go to Sugar Bowl on W Lemon St! You'll be glad you did.
I love this place , and I love giving them my business. Demetrious and Flora are incredible people and get the food out fast and make it delicious. So glad to have them in the City. If you have never been there, you need to check them out.
Location
-
601 W Lemon St, Lancaster, PA 17603, United States Hotline: +1 717-333-8808
If you find yourself in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, make sure to stop by Sugar Bowl Lancaster, located at 601 W Lemon St. This hidden gem is quickly becoming a favorite among locals for its welcoming atmosphere and delectable menu offerings. With a phone number of +1 717-333-8808, it’s just a call away for those looking to explore a fantastic dining experience.
From the moment you step inside, Sugar Bowl Lancaster greets you with a blend of charm and warmth that elevates your dining experience. Customers rave about the exceptional quality of the food, particularly the pizza, which is hailed for its crispy and buttery crust paired with the perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio. Whether you’re craving a personal small pie or sharing a larger one, this pizzeria doesn’t disappoint. Mario Rosario, a satisfied customer, remarks, “The pizza is great, especially the personal small pie,” highlighting the consistency of flavor that keeps customers coming back.
But Sugar Bowl Lancaster isn’t just about pizza. The menu boasts an extensive array of options sizable enough to satisfy every palate. Reviewers like K Martinez emphasize the cheeseburger subs, noting the perfect blend of fresh ingredients and taste that delivers a satisfying bite. Another customer, Jaidyn Coley, recalled enjoying a perfectly crafted BLT with crispy bacon and fresh produce, feeling comfortably full without the heaviness that often accompanies greasy meals. The attention to detail in each dish reflects the kitchen's commitment to quality, ensuring every ingredient shines.
The convenience of ordering at the counter, coupled with attentive table service, adds to the welcoming vibe. Customers like Michael Feigum appreciate the use of authentic ingredients for their sandwiches, noting the real Italian meats used in their Italian sandwich, which makes every bite memorable. The fries, hot and crispy, serve as an ideal side, complementing the delectable main courses.
Moreover, the ambiance is inviting, earning a unique balance between a sophisticated eatery and a cozy, roller rink vibe, making it a fitting spot for casual dining or a quick meal with friends. It’s this attention to service and detail, as noted by Jaidyn, who highlights the staff's effort to bring over extra napkins and condiments personally, that truly makes Sugar Bowl Lancaster stand out.
As you savor the delightful offerings, it’s clear that Sugar Bowl Lancaster is more than just a place to eat—it’s a community hub where good food and friendly conversation thrive. With fair prices, generous portions, and a welcoming atmosphere, this local treasure is worth every penny and visit.